|
 |
Sunday, September 07,
2003
|
Florida Homes:
Something to Build On
|
The forces driving up Florida home prices remain
strong — and are leading many developers to rethink traditional
strategies.
By Lewis M. Goodkin
Like other home builders across
the state, Steve O’Dowd is looking forward to a strong year. As president of Park
Square Homes, a production builder in Orlando, O’Dowd expects
to almost double his sales volume this year. “Last year we closed
about 450 homes,” he says, “and we should reach about 800 this
year.”
TREND: More
seond-cycle development -
older apartment buildings and hotels
being renovated and converted to
condominiums. |
Low interest rates and a bear market
on Wall Street have supported the nation’s housing market — and builders such
as O’Dowd — for three years now. Despite the 2001 recession
and weak recovery, 2002 was the strongest year for U.S.
housing on record, says Kermit Baker, chief economist of
the American Institute of Architects in Washington, D.C.
Homeownership rates, investment in new construction, home
sales, remodeling expenditures, home equity and mortgage
refinance volumes all hit highs, even in the face of widespread
job losses.
TREND: Continuing
relatively low interest
rates at least through 2003. |
Most indicators point to interest rates
remaining relatively low at least through 2003 — and to the housing market remaining
strong. Lawrence Yun, senior forecast economist for the
National Association of Realtors, says existing-home sales
will rise about 3%, while existing-home prices will climb
by about 6%. “People recognize that in the absence of stock
market hysteria, the home is a very good investment,” says
Noah Breakstone, president of Breakstone Homes in Coral
Gables.
Aside from interest rates, three factors
traditionally have had the most impact on Florida’s
housing market. Following is an assessment of the trends
in each of those
areas.
|
ADDING HOMES
|
States with the largest
gains in housing units
from July 1, 2001, to July 1, 2002: |
| 1. Texas |
149,208 |
| 2. Florida |
147,377 |
| 3. California |
130,779 |
| 4. Georgia |
87,909 |
| 5. North Carolina |
76,480 |
| Source: Census Bureau |
|
THROUGH
THE ROOF
|
The median existing-home
price in Florida is about
$10,000 below the U.S. median of $161,500. Here’s
how Florida cities compare with others on median price: |
| City |
Median
Price
|
| Anaheim / Santa Ana, Calif. |
$448,400
|
| Boston |
|
| Bergen / Passaic, N.J. |
358,300
|
| Honolulu |
350,000
|
| Los Angeles |
307,900
|
| Miami/Hialeah |
202,200
|
| Sarasota |
192,700
|
| Raleigh / Durham, N.C. |
173,000
|
| Bradenton |
156,500
|
| Austin / San Marcos, Texas |
151,700
|
| Tucson, Ariz. |
150,100
|
| Phoenix |
147,300
|
| Atlanta |
146,400
|
| Tampa /St. Petersburg
/ Clearwater |
137,800
|
| Orlando |
137,700
|
| Dallas |
134,900
|
| Fort Myers / Cape
Coral |
134,400
|
| Gainesville |
132,900
|
| Birmingham, Ala. |
131,900
|
| Tallahassee |
131,000
|
| Memphis |
129,300
|
| Melbourne / Titusville
/ Palm Bay |
124,900
|
| Jacksonville |
120,600
|
| Pensacola |
111,000
|
| Daytona Beach |
110,900
|
| San Antonio |
108,700
|
| Rochester, N.Y. |
90,400
|
| Fort Wayne, Ind. |
86,600
|
| Syracuse, N.Y. |
85,100
|
| Waterloo/Cedar Falls, Iowa |
80,700
|
| Region |
Median
Price
|
| West |
$217,200
|
| Northeast |
178,500
|
| South |
152,200
|
| Midwest |
134,700
|
Source: National Association
of Realtors, first-quarter 2003,
preliminary |
LAND AVAILABILITY
In the next decade, availability of land will be the
single largest factor shaping the state’s primary housing
market. Urban counties like Pinellas and Broward are
nearing build-out, and new-home starts are
falling in Miami-Dade County as well. For the first five months of
2003, building permits fell 18% in Miami-Dade and 37% in Broward while
rising 28% in Palm Beach County. Because of land availability and affordability
issues, St. Lucie County is shaping up to become the next high-growth
market in south Florida. Orlando also enjoys a substantial land supply,
transportation network and airport that are attractive to new employers.
With their lower land costs, northwest and north Florida
will gradually take a larger share of the state’s retirement
market, especially in the moderate-priced segment,
which now centers on the Ocala area. While
water and golf have always been major driving forces in attracting
retirees, these amenities will carry increasingly higher costs and
push up home prices.
With land growing more scarce, areas near the Atlantic and Gulf coasts
will continue to see more second-cycle development. Older apartment
buildings and once-fashionable hotels like The Collins on Miami Beach
are being renovated and converted to condominiums. In Miami-Dade County,
second-cycle development is under way in neighborhoods many miles from
the ocean, including downtown Miami, North Bay Village and the Biscayne
Boulevard corridor.
“In south Florida, the push for ‘eastward ho’ is creating the strongest urban
land boom since the 1920s,” says Mike Pappas, president of The Keyes Co. in Miami. “The
supply of land is so limited by the ocean and the Everglades while demand remains
very strong. That’s why there are so many new developments in the downtown and
eastern suburban areas.”
While Miami has led the way, second-cycle
redevelopment is happening more frequently in the state’s
most urbanized areas, as well as in their closest suburbs.
| TREND: Increasing
numbers of non-traditional households, including
singles, unmarried couples without children,
single parents with children and same-sex couples. |
DEMOGRAPHICS
Florida’s population will continue to grow quickly. An estimated 330,000
people are expected to move to Florida in 2003, up slightly from the
previous year. In contrast to many states’ experience, a majority of
buyers of new and resale homes in Florida come from outside the state,
although in 2001 nearly as many Floridians changed addresses within Florida
(at least 234,000 people, according to the IRS) as moved here from other
states (at least 260,000).
Florida’s primary migration flows
continue to be from the Northeast and Midwest. Recent
years also have seen
a growing stream of Californians selling expensive homes
and moving to the lower-cost climate here. European and
Latin American buyers are important factors in the south
Florida and Orlando markets, although they tend to be
vacation-home buyers.
Another demographic trend involves
shifts in the age distribution of the state’s population that will spur
higher spending on both remodeling and new-home purchases
in the coming years. Baker notes that by 2010, older
Baby Boomers will be in their peak wealth years and younger
Boomers will be in the peak-earning ages of 45 to 54. “The
Boomers will still be an important force in home-buying
markets because of their sheer numbers and economic clout,” he
says.
While working-age families have traditionally
been drawn to the state’s urban centers like Tampa Bay, Jacksonville,
Orlando and south Florida, retirees or “active adults” prefer
communities outside urban centers. Typically, this means
central Florida, led by developments like The Villages
in Lake County, and southwest Florida, whose country
club communities have resulted in spectacular population
growth in areas like Bonita Springs, Estero and Cape
Coral.
| TREND: Affordability
issues. Annual appreciation rates of 10% to 25%
in some markets have nudged prices out of reach
of many new buyers. Affordable housing has become
an important issue in Florida communities from
Orlando to Miami. |
While in-migration will continue to be a big factor
in Florida’s housing
markets, retiring Baby Boomers may not be moving as far as their parents
did. A recent study by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)
and Countrywide Home Loans indicates that most buyers age 50 and older
are likely to choose a location close to their current home. “Baby
Boomers and older home buyers want a maintenance-free lifestyle, freeing
them up to travel, socialize and pursue the active lifestyles they
want to lead,” says Kent Conine, NAHB president.
“At the same time,” adds Conine, “the
study dispels the common perception that seniors prefer
to move to
traditional warm-weather retirement destinations like
their parents did. An overwhelming majority of seniors
want to live near their loved ones or in the communities
where they have put down roots.”
That live-close-to-home trend means
Florida builders may have to market more to aging Boomers
within the state’s
larger markets and less to out-of-state buyers. However,
Florida’s ability to offer both luxury and affordable
retirement homes, combined with a low-tax environment,
means the state will continue to maintain its lead in
this market.
COST
As suitable land becomes more scarce, labor costs are
rising. In addition, developmental regulations
and impact fees and other growth management
requirements add to a developer’s costs. Those factors are reflected
in higher new-home prices, smaller lots and more town home and condominium
construction. Research indicates there will always be a market for
traditional single-family detached homes in Florida. But increasingly,
the trend in primary housing will be toward homes on smaller lots,
more two-story town homes and urban condominiums, especially in the
more developed counties.
TREND: Some
increase in housing
market risks. "Job losses have
forced more mortgage holders into
foreclosure, increased the number of
homeowners spending half of their
income on housing and softened
some rental markets." |
Rising prices also will result in conversions of rental
apartments to condominium ownership. Price will become
the ultimate amenity as more buyers look at multifamily
units for their primary residences.
In addition, growth management restrictions in many
communities will make it increasingly difficult to build
large-scale planned communities like Palm Coast in Flagler
County, Weston in Broward and Lakewood Ranch in Sarasota.
On the other hand, new communities
like Victoria Park in DeLand and Harmony in Osceola
County are making a
virtue out of today’s environmental requirements. About
40% of the 1,800 acres at Victoria Park will be set aside
for open space, gardens, parks and recreation, while
11,000-acre Harmony includes two lakes surrounded by
wetlands and a forested area.
The combination of land scarcity and
rising costs is forcing many developers to rethink
their traditional
strategies. For instance, Miami-based Lennar Corp., one
of the nation’s largest builders, is shifting its emphasis
in south Florida from large-scale suburban communities
to smaller condominiums in urban settings. By 2008, CEO
Stuart Miller expects single-family homes to be just
36% of Lennar’s total south Florida sales.
Condominium developments like the
Grande in Kendall and 360° in North Bay Village can be more affordable
than single-family homes and can be more easily squeezed
into urban infill sites. “At 360°, we sold more than
100 residences in 90 days,” says Carlos Gonzalez, vice
president of sales and marketing for Lennar’s subsidiary
LDI. “In this day of skyrocketing waterfront real estate
prices, buyers want to know that ‘value’ figures into
the equation.”
TIMESHARES
Fractional ownership is the fastest-growing segment
in resort real estate, according to the American Resort
Development Association.
In November, the Ritz-Carlton Golf
Club & Spa is
set to open in Jupiter, selling vacationers who want
to enjoy golf, tennis, spa activities or other amenities
a one-eighth interest in one of 67 club homes, starting
at $221,000.
The Residence Club at Lighthouse Pointe in Amelia Island
offers 40 four-bedroom homes. Like other new timeshares,
the Amelia Island property caters to buyers who want
larger units.
A HIGH-DENSITY FUTURE
The state’s housing market is becoming
increasingly diverse. Loft residences, for instance,
are a popular
new option in transitional urban neighborhoods. Projects
like NeoLofts on the Miami River and Westside Lofts on
Miami Beach are selling briskly.
Higher-density housing is playing
an increasingly important role in virtually all price
ranges. The lines between
single-family detached and attached homes will begin
to blur as town homes and coach homes — buildings with
access to first-floor and upper-floor apartments directly
from the street level — become more available.
The latest generation of high-end condos offers private
elevators and personal services and amenities previously
found only in luxury resorts.
Developers will be challenged to
offer the most popular amenities at affordable prices.
The likelihood is that
most Floridians will have to accept smaller residences.
Smaller condos and town homes may become the only way
to offer “starter” housing to the next generation.
Lewis M. Goodkin is president of Miami-based
Goodkin Consulting, a strategic alliance with PricewaterhouseCoopers
|
|